# Are We Still Doing Mini Apps? Source: https://open.substack.com/pub/nickysap/p/are-we-still-doing-mini-apps?r=3ptcv Kiwi News: https://news.kiwistand.com/stories/Are-We-Still-Doing-Mini-Apps?index=0x69eefb2061e98dedba4a57337486dfd52f829c880c09bced76839b4ba2c899cb2db30f57 Submitted by tim on 2026-04-27 UTC, 3 upvotes, 0 comments ## Summary The author argues that Mini Apps have largely failed as a standalone distribution model, so builders have moved on, and that AI coding tools and native apps now handle distribution. Their own Solana Farcaster Mini App grew from under 1,000 users to over 30,000 in one day in May 2025, but fewer than 1% of those users did anything beyond adding it. Hamster Kombat's Telegram user base fell from 300 million to 13.1 million by February 2025, and Notcoin's players dropped from 35 million in March 2024 to under 1 million by July 2025. Lovable reached $400 million ARR and Cursor $2 billion ARR, which the author cites as evidence that the builders who get paid are often AI tool companies. ## Article Were mini apps just the kiosks in someone else’s mall? In May of 2025, I was sitting in the back of a conference hall at Solana Accelerate in New York City when the Farcaster team went on stage to announce their big news. Solana on Farcaster was finally a reality, and the flagship Mini App that was promoted on the big screen was the one I built. Within minutes, our Mini App was flooded with users. The servers were burning down as I scrambled to scale compute. When the dust settled, I checked the metrics and could hardly believe we had gone from less than 1,000 users to over 30,000 in a single day. Mini Apps are the future. Distribution is solved. Customer acquisition cost was near-zero. We’re early. At least I thought. Over the following days, I noticed that, while we had achieved supranormal growth on paper, the revenue figures weren’t following the same trend. Most of these users weren’t performing any actions onchain. In fact, fewer than 1% of them did anything other than open and add the mini app, never to be seen again. The pitch was legit When Mini Apps hit Farcaster, they weren’t a new concept, so the thesis was clear, and it seemed to play out, at first. Within just weeks of the release, we saw apps like Farcade reach 100,000 users, and Bracky see a 500%+ lift per game thanks to Mini App distribution. On Telegram, Hamster Kombat was pushing numbers unfathomable to even the most well-allocated, VC-backed consumer tech teams. A game with 300 million users, where you tap the screen. World App had over 2.2 billion opens, and millions of users were verified with the eye-scanning Orb. If you were paying attention at this time and you were an aspirational builder, your head was spinning, and your thinking was laser-focused on this new moat. The wave of the Everything App was upon us. We would soon have a Super App that would integrate into our daily lives, offer everything we needed across the value chain, and enable builders to bootstrap their ideas cheaply. But the reality behind these numbers was actually quite damning. Selling the farm When I realized that the majority of the 30,000 users who had added our Mini App were simply farming an upcoming airdrop, I assumed others would fall to the same fate. It wasn’t until recently, however, that I’ve been able to prove it with empirical evidence. Hamster Kombat had to disqualify more than a third of its userbase from the airdrop. After the airdrop, users declined further, from 300M to 13.1M, by February of 2025. By the time they released season two, daily active user figures were in the low thousands. Their token, $HMSTR, is down 98%+ from its all-time high. Notcoin dropped from 35M players in March of 2024 to fewer than 1M users of their sticker store by July of 2025. The original game shuttered. The $NOT token is down nearly 99%. The graveyard of Telegram Mini Apps rivals Arlington National and accounts for the largest user-churn event in crypto’s history, collapsing from 1.44B users at its peak in September 2024 to less than 150M by mid-2025. While Telegram introduced some tightly gatekept platform updates at the beginning of 2025 that may have contributed to this churn, these changes can’t account for attrition of this scale. Regardless, in the wake of this disastrous decline, a reasonably strong user base continued to access Telegram’s DeFi ecosystem. The TON Wallet had roughly 87M users as of July 2025, and the DEX and trading products that survived are doing solid (albeit comparatively low) volume. The platform remains, the builders departed, and the users lost most of what they put in. The Base App, Coinbase’s flagship DeFi wallet, was billed as a Super App during its launch on July 16, 2025. They released an SDK that was backward-compatible with Farcaster’s Mini App ecosystem (it wasn’t really). Six months later, Mini Apps were deprecated, the Farcaster integration was ripped out, and they pivoted to a “trading-first” focus. Base Creator Rewards paid less than $30 per creator over the lifetime of this debacle. That said, the Base L2 remains a thriving cash machine for Coinbase, generating $15M+ in sequencer fees in Q4 2025. Alongside Arbitrum, Base contributes 77% of all DeFi TVL across Ethereum L2 rollups. The chain is winning. The users, creators, and builders, not so much. Contrast these with World App, which appears to be the only Mini App ecosystem with positive growth. World App has over 150 Mini Apps, 100M+ downloads, and has been opened 2.25 billion times as of April 24, 2026. Of the roughly 37 million users on World App, nearly half are Orb-verified humans, which means they stood in front of a VC-backed iris scanner and sent that information to the cloud in exchange for some schillings. Those schillings, by the way, are basically the core use case for World App, whose top Mini App is Worldcoin’s own airdrop claim app. In fact, 40% of all Mini App activity on World is humans claiming their $WLD. The Mini Apps that follow the leader are pseudo-financialized engagement loops, ORO and UNO, with the rest of the top ten list being dominated by financial apps (earn hubs, lending, swap/send). While these outcomes are not super exciting, they do demonstrate that human verification can create a more sustainable ecosystem for builders and users alike. World App is the only Mini App hosting platform to have recently increased its developer rewards, paying out $100,000/week to top teams (up from $25,000/week in Q1 of 2025). Web3 didn’t invent this failure mode, though. Elon Musk bought Twitter 3.5 years ago, promising the same thing. "In the months to come, we will add comprehensive communications and the ability to conduct your entire financial world." - Elon Musk While this aspiration was exciting, even admirable, the truth is that achieving such a vision is unbelievably difficult from a regulatory and technical perspective. As of April 24, 2026, X has acquired 41 state money transmitter licenses + DC, leaving a seven-state delta in their regulatory roadmap. They were denied in New York. X Money was reportedly launching this month (April, 2026), nine months late. It’s still not out of beta. There are no Mini Apps on X. Their APIs are gatekept, expensive, and hardly what one would call expressive. Users can trade equities and crypto in one jurisdiction (Canada). Musk may yet ship something. But 3.5 years and 41 state licenses deep, the case for Super Apps in the West still isn’t getting stronger. So, are we still doing Mini Apps? When Mini Apps emerged in 2022, shipping software remained a bottleneck in the distribution pipeline. Even with the AI tooling available, you still had to know how to code. Mini Apps offered a surface on which a developer could bootstrap an idea, distribute it to a large group of users on a platform they already accessed daily, and validate it before diving into the headache of shipping a full production app. In 2026, that bottleneck is more like the wide berth at the mouth of a river. You’ve heard all the clichés about shipping no longer being the moat; I’ll spare you. The relevant point is that the problem Mini Apps were built to solve has been solved by something else. Pieter Levels shipped a Three.js flying game and hit a projected $1M ARR, solo, in 17 days. Peter Steinberger dropped OpenClaw, which became the fastest-growing open-source software project ever, and was acquired by OpenAI six weeks later. Moltbook, a platform with mostly fake users, was acqui-hired by Meta Superintelligence Labs. It didn’t matter that both were bug-ridden security nightmares. None of these needed a host platform to seed their user bases. The unifying throughline here is distribution. They were popular. They got attention. The thing that Mini Apps were supposed to achieve for builders has been completely subsumed by vibe coding and virality. But in most cases, the people who are reliably getting paid aren’t the builders. Cursor achieved $2B ARR in two years, with a recent $60B acquisition option from xAI. Claude Code raked in $2.5B six months after it launched. Lovable hit $400M ARR. Replit Agent is doing $253M ARR. Vercel’s v0 reached $42M ARR, accounting for 21% of their topline. AI tool companies have doubled their revenue since 2024. Who knew the Super App we were dreaming about would be an IDE? So are we building Mini Apps or pivoting to native? Neither. Standalone Mini App platforms (read: Super Apps) are contracting on their theses. Most builders have already pivoted to building native or web apps. The Mini App form factor is being absorbed into apps that already have distribution nailed as features rather than destinations. Neither is right nor wrong if you can beat the attention machine against the other ten million vibe coders shipping the same idea as you. But none of us could have known that in 2024. I still drop Mini Apps, but only when they complement something native I’ve already shipped. Share