How Hacker News Ranking Really Works

Submit
righto.com

How hacker news ranking really works

AI summary of the linked article

The article reports an analysis of Hacker News ranking, finding that the published scoring formula is mostly accurate but that many articles are penalized in ways the formula does not show. The author states that about 20% of front-page stories and 38% of second-page stories had been penalized, and that titles containing "NSA" receive an automatic penalty of .4. The author also describes a "controversy" penalty that becomes active once a story reaches 40 comments, which can cause a story to drop sharply or vanish from the top 60, and suspects the exponent is 3 rather than the published 2.

Recommended by 3 curators
avatar
Fun fact: We used this algorithm in the beginning, but it turned out that there weren‘t enough new posts with enough upvotes and it was quite easy to get on the front page.

Our algorithm for the front page has since then become way more complex and, for example, can require a higher upvote count when there are many good stories at the same time.

The algorithm‘s variables also always need slight tweaking so that stories disappear or remain on the feed. It depends on how many users are active in a week and at what hours they‘re active etc.


I could probably go on, it‘s an art in itself to build such an algorithm. I did it by just using the site quite a lot and a looooot of trial and error until I liked it.
avatar
> "I observed that many websites appear to automatically get a penalty of .25 to .8: arstechnica.com, businessinsider.com, easypost.com, github.com, imgur.com, medium.com, quora.com, qz.com, reddit.com, rt.com, stackexchange.com, theguardian.com, theregister.com, theverge.com, torrentfreak.com, youtube.com"

(...)

> "If an article gets a penalty factor of .4, this is equivalent to each vote only counting as .3 votes. Alternatively, the article will drop in ranking 66% faster than normal. A penalty factor of .1 corresponds to each vote counting as .05 votes, or the article dropping at 3.6 times the normal rate"

This seems... pretty harsh.

I understand that they want to give more space to less popular sources. Plus, I can understand why torrentfreak.com got into that list, but penalizing GitHub and StackExchange is pretty weird on the website called *Hacker* News.