@vgr: Protocols as skeletal horror vs AI's flesh horror - crypto's dual nature

Submit
farcaster.xyz

@vgr: Protocols as skeletal horror vs AI's flesh horror - crypto's dual nature

AI summary of the linked article

Vitalik Buterin's (no, the author is @vgr, Vitalik Buterin is not named in the text) — correction: the text is a short social media post by @vgr, and it argues that crypto protocols should be framed as a skeletal horror, the counterpart to AI's flesh horror. It contrasts protocols' fixed shapes, barriers and deterministic constraint with AI's shape-shifting, ooze-like nature. The post says normies find crypto cringe and that crypto people wrongly try to make it "Fun," and it suggests the real task is to make crypto a dual horror to AI, characterized by mindless, crystalline determinism and a sharp split between absolute freedom and absolute constraint.

avatar
lol I have no idea what any of that means
avatar
I suppose it's related to his study of oozification in tech and AI, so tech horror as a pair:
- AI/ooze/shoggoth: Fluid, playful, and potentially uncontrollable
- Protocols/skeleton: Rigid, deterministic, potentially oppressive

AI is fun (when playful), crypto people try and fail to make protocols fun? ("Protocol can also be a selling point")
avatar
Yes, but I think he means crypto people try to make something ‘fun’ - fluid that is actually meant to be rigid. (in order to sell it to the normies either subconsciously or not, why it’s misguided). Instead crypto should be the skeleton for the AI flesh (that what is potentially uncontrollable made deterministic). The dual horror the idea that crypto can be a means to, as well as a boundary. The one who knocks.

Anyway that’s what I make of it ;)
avatar
Idk I get the impression that AI and its propaganda is often very rigid because have you ever tried to argue against an LLM a position that is political consensus but potentially still wrong. It's just so annoying how it rigidly brings you back to whatever is in the model weights. At the same time, for Kiwi News at least, I've discovered that while true, protocols are like skeletons, the muscles make those move quite flexibly. I mean did you know that the Kiwi News protocol is still largely the same as it was two years ago, but the client's usability has massively improved.

Anyways, I do agree that we're trying to make something fun that is otherwise rather boring.

I didn't get the dual horror idea. Is there more to read on this maybe?
avatar
"lol I have no idea what any of that means"

this is my impression about 50% of the time when i read vgr's posts
avatar