@CCDDBB: Tuukzs used AI to copy Kim Asendorf's Monogrid style, and Kim objected

Submit
@CCDDBB
@CCDDBB

Today’s Twitter drama in our peculiar little world of crypto art has been the heated exchange between Tuukzs and Kim Asendorf. Tuukzs mentioned Kim in a post, explaining how much of an inspiration he has been to him, particularly his Monogrid series. The post featured a washed-out derivative of Kim’s algorithm, presented as the result of a “study” of his work. To be fair, the post didn’t mention that Tuukzs doesn’t know how to code and had used AI to reproduce the look of Kim’s work. Needless to say, Kim didn’t like it one bit. His response was pretty sharp and annoyed, maybe even excessive, or at least that’s how I perceived it. But I totally understand where his frustration is coming from. Artists have always copied other artists to learn, a practice that has been crucial to how art has evolved over the centuries. But there is a fundamental difference between spending weeks trying to reproduce a painting in order to understand its techniques and uncover its secrets, and using Ai to generate something that simply looks like another artist’s work. Learning should happen through the process, and with Ai it is possible to achieve a pretty convincing result without the need to understand any of the underlying complexities of the original work. And in generative art, this difference matters a lot, because algorithms, constraints and constant experimentation are at the very core of the practice. It can take years to develop a recognizable visual language, sometimes even decades. And it becomes part of an artist identity. Seeing that identity reproduced in minutes by someone who hasn’t put in the work that was once necessary can be very, very painful. It has nothing to do with owning a style, as some are trying to paint it, or preventing others from experimenting. It’s about recognizing and respecting the whole work that went into developing that recognizable visual language. And I think this little controversy reflects something much bigger about the period we're living in. AI is by far the most divisive technology I have witnessed in my lifetime. Its possibilities are extraordinary, and I am truly fascinated by them. I use AI myself and I genuinely appreciate what it makes possible to achieve. But that doesn't mean I have to celebrate or accept everything that comes with it. We are witnessing a massive disruption of the creative professions. These new technologies are often trained with no regards for copyright and artists consent, and with practices that are far from being transparent. Not to mention the absurd environmental impact they are having and the social issues they are causing. And all this to produce an economic transformation that is rendering skills people spent their whole lives to develop suddenly much harder to market in order to make a living from them. And the answer to all this is too often reductive and insensitive: adapt. I used to make that argument myself, until some difficult conversations with people I care about made me realize how unfair and painful it can be. Not everyone wants to adapt, and not everyone has the same capacity to do it. Older artists, neurodivergent people, artists whose entire practice revolves around physical skills, people with families to support and little financial security. Some are embracing these tools and thriving, others are clearly not. And many simply don't want to participate in a system whose ethics they fundamentally disagree with. That doesn't make them ignorant, lazy or afraid of progress. If anything, it shows integrity and soul. Meanwhile, the internet is being flooded with an endless stream of beautiful and impressive images that lack of depth. So many that I'm increasingly finding myself scrolling past them without feeling anything. When extraordinary looking images become ordinary, it becomes much harder for genuinely personal work to be noticed and appreciated. We're slowly losing the patience to distinguish between an interesting image and an interesting artistic practice. And for artists already struggling to make a living, that over saturation only makes things worse. There's also something deeply sad about how Ai is changing the way we learn. It used to involve reaching out to people and asking questions in order to exchange knowledge, and in doing so we were building relationships. Today we can increasingly bypass all that, getting answers and results without ever interacting with another human being. It's incredibly empowering, but I wonder how many meaningful connections we'll lose along the way. I am afraid many. Too many. I obviously don't think it is possible to stop this transformation. I hope some wonderful things will come out of it, and eventually we'll find some kind of balance. But we are far from it. Right now, some people are discovering extraordinary opportunities while others are watching the value of their life's work collapse. Both realities deserve to be acknowledged, and in the second case with a greater level of sensitivity. Going back to Kim and Tuukzs, I believe the admiration was sincere and I don't think experimenting with another artist work should be forbidden. But giving credit doesn't automatically make an imitation respectful, and having the ability to reproduce something doesn't mean we should not consider whether publishing it is appropriate. I wish we could live this transition with a little more sensitivity and respect. If someone has spent years developing a distinctive technique or visual language we should acknowledge what that represents. We can study and experiment with it and eventually take it somewhere new. And perhaps we should think twice before flooding an already saturated space with something that closely resembles their work. Not everything that can be reproduced needs to be reproduced.

x.com

@CCDDBB: Tuukzs used AI to copy Kim Asendorf's Monogrid style, and Kim objected

AI summary of the linked article

The author argues that using AI to reproduce another artist's visual style differs from traditional learning by copying, and that this matters in generative art. The essay uses a dispute between Tuukzs and Kim Asendorf as its example. Tuukzs posted a washed-out derivative of Kim's algorithm, presented as a "study" of his Monogrid series, without mentioning that he does not code and had used AI to reproduce the look of Kim's work. The essay's main point is that AI can produce convincing results without understanding the original work, and that developing a recognizable visual language can take years, so the author calls for more sensitivity and asks whether publishing such imitations is appropriate.

No comments yetWhat caught your eye? Start the discussion.