@pcaversaccio: Zama's FHE stack is vendor-dependent privacy, not cypherpunk

Submit
@pcaversaccio
@pcaversaccio
Replying to @zama

stop the clownshow guys, this is _not_ cypherpunk privacy. it's vendor-dependent privacy. your code license grants no patent rights, so commercial deployments need Zama's permission. permissionless systems require independent implementations, but a patent moat actively discourages them. if Zama disappears, who maintains & upgrades the stack? you currently fail the walkaway test and are nowhere near CROPS-aligned. you can do better.

Tweet image
x.com

@pcaversaccio: Zama's FHE stack is vendor-dependent privacy, not cypherpunk

AI summary of the linked article

The post argues that Zama's fully homomorphic encryption stack is vendor-dependent privacy rather than cypherpunk privacy. It states that Zama's code license grants no patent rights, so commercial deployments need Zama's permission, and that a patent moat discourages the independent implementations permissionless systems require. The author asks who would maintain and upgrade the stack if Zama disappeared, and concludes that the project fails the "walkaway test" and is not CROPS-aligned.

No comments yetWhat caught your eye? Start the discussion.